Factors and change map
Crime and punishment across the four periods: what happened to crimes, law enforcement and punishment, and how the three factors shaped them.
- Similarity or difference (4 marks): read along one row, and pick a detail from each of the two periods in the question.
- How far do you agree? (16 marks): read down a period's column to weigh the factor in the statement against the others, and along the rows to judge how much changed.
The three strands
Crimes
c1000–c1500
- Most crime was petty theft, often of food or animals, by poor people.
- The Normans' Forest Laws made hunting in royal forests a crime, so poaching became far more common.
c1500–c1700
- Most crime was still petty theft.
- After the Reformation, heresy and treason became more important crimes against authority, as the Gunpowder Plot shows.
- New crimes: vagabondage, and witchcraft (Acts of 1542, 1563 and 1604).
Notes: Crime in early modern England · The Gunpowder Plotters · Matthew Hopkins and the witch-hunts
c1700–c1900
- Petty theft was still the most common crime.
- Highway robbery, poaching and smuggling rose, then fell.
- Changing definitions: the Witchcraft Act of 1736 ended witchcraft prosecutions, while the Tolpuddle Martyrs were punished for a union oath (1834).
Notes: Crime in the 18th and 19th centuries · The Tolpuddle Martyrs
c1900–present
- Theft is still the most common crime.
- Old crimes take new forms: car crime and cyber crime; drug and people smuggling.
- New laws created driving offences, race crimes and drug crimes; refusing to fight was treated as a crime against authority.
Law enforcement
c1000–c1500
- No police: the community enforced the law through tithings and the hue and cry.
- Royal officials grew in number: sheriffs, coroners, travelling judges and, from the 14th century, Justices of the Peace.
- Trial by ordeal ended after 1215, and trial by jury took its place.
Notes: Anglo-Saxon and Norman justice · Law and punishment in later medieval England · The Church and crime
c1500–c1700
- Still no police: unpaid parish constables, town watchmen and the hue and cry.
- Justices of the Peace became more important.
- Growing towns made the old system, where everyone knew everyone, work less well.
c1700–c1900
- The Fieldings' Bow Street Runners (1749) were London's first paid law-enforcers.
- Peel's Metropolitan Police (1829) patrolled beats to prevent crime.
- Every county and town had a force by 1856; the CID began in 1878.
Notes: Robert Peel and the police
c1900–present
- Specialist units, from the Flying Squad (1919) to the National Crime Agency (2013).
- Fingerprints, the 999 number, the Police National Computer, DNA and CCTV.
- A move towards prevention, with the community again helping: Neighbourhood Watch (1982).
Notes: Modern policing
Punishment
c1000–c1500
- Aims: deterrence and retribution, so punishments were public and harsh.
- Fines were the most common punishment; also the stocks, pillory, whipping and mutilation, and hanging for serious crimes.
- The wergild ended: fines were paid to the king, not the victim.
Notes: Law and punishment in later medieval England · Anglo-Saxon and Norman justice
c1500–c1700
- Still public and harsh: the stocks, pillory and whipping; hanging; burning for heresy.
- Traitors such as the Gunpowder Plotters were hanged, drawn and quartered (1606).
- New: transportation to America, and the start of the Bloody Code (about 50 capital crimes by the 1680s).
Notes: Early modern law enforcement and punishment · The Gunpowder Plotters
c1700–c1900
- The Bloody Code grew to over 200 capital crimes, then was cut back from the 1820s.
- Transportation to Australia (1787–1868); public executions ended in 1868.
- Prisons replaced them, aiming to reform: Pentonville's separate system (1842).
Notes: Punishment and prison reform, c1700–c1900 · Pentonville prison
c1900–present
- The death penalty for murder was suspended in 1965 and abolished for good in 1969.
- Prisons aim to reform; open prisons, and separate treatment of young offenders.
- Non-custodial sentences: probation, community service and electronic tagging.
Notes: Modern punishment · The Derek Bentley case
The factors
Attitudes in society
c1000–c1500
- The community was responsible for keeping order.
- People believed God would show the truth, so trial by ordeal was accepted.
- Harsh public punishment was accepted.
Notes: Anglo-Saxon and Norman justice · Law and punishment in later medieval England
c1500–c1700
- Fear of vagabonds: the 'undeserving poor' were seen as a threat to order.
- Most people believed in witches; religious change and hard times bred fear.
Notes: Crime in early modern England · Matthew Hopkins and the witch-hunts
c1700–c1900
- A growing belief that punishment should reform criminals, not just deter.
- Juries refused to convict under the Bloody Code; public pressure freed the Tolpuddle Martyrs.
Notes: Punishment and prison reform, c1700–c1900 · The Tolpuddle Martyrs
c1900–present
- Unease after cases such as Derek Bentley's helped end the death penalty.
- Concern about race and drugs led to new crimes; COs were treated more fairly in the Second World War.
Notes: The Derek Bentley case · Crime in modern Britain · Conscientious objectors
Individuals and institutions
c1000–c1500
- Kings: crime became an offence against the king's peace; William I's Forest Laws and murdrum fine.
- The Church: its own courts, benefit of clergy and sanctuary; in 1215 it ended trial by ordeal.
Notes: Anglo-Saxon and Norman justice · The Church and crime
c1500–c1700
- Monarchs changed the official religion, making heresy and treason major crimes.
- James I wrote about witches; Hopkins and Stearne led the witch-hunts of 1645–47.
- Parliament, made up of landowners, began the Bloody Code.
Notes: Crime in early modern England · Matthew Hopkins and the witch-hunts · Early modern law enforcement and punishment
c1700–c1900
- The Fieldings and Robert Peel changed policing.
- John Howard and Elizabeth Fry exposed prison conditions; Peel's Gaols Act (1823).
- Parliament passed the Acts that made the changes.
Notes: Robert Peel and the police · Punishment and prison reform, c1700–c1900
c1900–present
- Government laws created new crimes, such as the Race Relations Act 1965 and the Misuse of Drugs Act 1971.
- Specialist police units; the Bentley family's campaign won a partial pardon (1993), and his conviction was quashed (1998).
Notes: Crime in modern Britain · Modern policing · The Derek Bentley case
Science and technology
c1000–c1500
- Little effect: law enforcement relied on people, not technology.
Notes: Factors and change
c1500–c1700
- Printing spread ideas, such as pamphlets about witches.
Notes: Factors and change · Matthew Hopkins and the witch-hunts
c1700–c1900
- Faster transport and the telegraph.
Notes: Factors and change
c1900–present
- Fingerprints, DNA, CCTV and computers help identify and catch criminals.
- But cars and the internet also created new crimes.
Notes: Modern policing · Crime in modern Britain