9 marks · about 12 minutes · +3 SPaG
To what extent has urban growth created opportunities for people in an LIC or NEE city? Use a case study.
To what extent means: Weigh up how far something is true, with evidence on both sides, then give a clear judgement.
Level 1 (Basic)· 3/9 marks (band 1–3)
Rio has jobs and the Olympics were there. But lots of people live in favelas, so not everyone has opportunities.
Why this level: Simple points with little detail and an undeveloped judgement. To reach Level 2: explain the social and economic opportunities in Rio, with facts.
Level 2 (Clear)· 5/9 marks (band 4–6)
Urban growth has created opportunities in Rio de Janeiro. There are more hospitals, schools and universities than in rural areas, and more homes have mains water and electricity. Rio is a major port and a centre of oil, finance and media; Petrobras has its head office there. The 2016 Olympics brought investment in transport.
Why this level: Clear social and economic opportunities from Rio. But it doesn't consider who misses out, so "to what extent" isn't answered. To reach Level 3: weigh the opportunities against how unevenly they are shared, then judge.
Level 3 (Detailed)· 8/9 marks (band 7–9)
Urban growth has created real opportunities in Rio de Janeiro. Socially, there are more hospitals, schools and universities than in rural areas, so migrants from Brazil's north-east can get better healthcare and education, and more homes have mains water and electricity. Economically, Rio is a major port and a centre of oil, finance and media, with Petrobras's head office there, and tourism employs many people. Hosting the 2016 Olympic Games brought investment in transport. However, these opportunities are not shared equally. Across Brazil, about 40% of workers had informal jobs in 2019, without contracts or security, and Rocinha, Brazil's largest favela, had 72,021 residents in 2022. Favelas often have poorer services than richer districts, and much of the city's sewage still flows untreated into Guanabara Bay. Overall, urban growth has created many opportunities, but they are unevenly shared: richer residents benefit most, while many of the poor gain only partly.
Why this level: Detailed, accurate evidence of social and economic opportunities, weighed against inequality, with a clear judgement on "to what extent". This is Level 3.