9 marks · about 9 minutes
Evaluate the opportunities and challenges of developing a cold environment.
Evaluate means: Judge strengths and weaknesses or successes and failures, then reach a conclusion.
Level 1 (Basic)· 3/9 marks (band 1–3)
Alaska has oil and fish, which bring money. But it is very cold and hard to build there.
Why this level: Simple opportunities and challenges with little detail and no judgement. To reach Level 2: use facts from Alaska to explain the opportunities and the challenges.
Level 2 (Clear)· 5/9 marks (band 4–6)
Alaska has many opportunities. Oil was found at Prudhoe Bay in 1968, and it is North America's largest oil field. Alaska also lands about 60% of the USA's seafood. However, development is difficult: the cold and permafrost mean buildings must stand on piles, and the Trans-Alaska Pipeline had to be raised on supports so the warm oil doesn't thaw the permafrost.
Why this level: Clear, accurate opportunities and challenges from Alaska. But it doesn't evaluate which outweigh the other. To reach Level 3: weigh them up, including costs and changes over time, and reach a judgement.
Level 3 (Detailed)· 8/9 marks (band 7–9)
Alaska shows the great opportunities of cold environments. Oil was found at Prudhoe Bay in 1968, North America's largest oil field, bringing jobs and wealth to the state. Alaska lands about 60% of the USA's seafood by weight, and mines such as Fort Knox gold mine and Red Dog zinc mine provide minerals. Tourists visit its mountains and coast. However, the challenges are serious. Extreme cold and inaccessibility make building costly, and heated buildings can thaw the permafrost and sink, so they must stand on piles or gravel pads. The Trans-Alaska Pipeline, finished in 1977, had to be raised on supports with heat pipes over half its length, and zigzags so it survived a magnitude 7.9 earthquake in 2002. Prudhoe Bay's output has also fallen since the 1980s. Overall, Alaska's opportunities have been developed successfully, but only through expensive engineering, and as the climate warms and permafrost thaws, the challenges are growing.
Why this level: Detailed, accurate evidence on opportunities and challenges, evaluated with the role of technology and a judgement that looks ahead. This is Level 3.