9 marks · about 9 minutes
To what extent does a large-scale agricultural development you have studied bring more advantages than disadvantages?
To what extent means: Weigh up how far something is true, with evidence on both sides, then give a clear judgement.
Level 1 (Basic)· 3/9 marks (band 1–3)
Thanet Earth grows lots of tomatoes in greenhouses. But it uses gas. I think it has more advantages.
Why this level: A named example, with simple points and an unsupported judgement. To reach Level 2: use facts to explain the advantages and disadvantages.
Level 2 (Clear)· 5/9 marks (band 4–6)
Thanet Earth, in Kent, is the UK's largest greenhouse complex. It grows about 400 million tomatoes a year hydroponically, all year round, which cuts imports and food miles, and creates local jobs. However, its combined heat and power plants burn natural gas, and it was built on farmland.
Why this level: Clear, accurate advantages and disadvantages. But they aren't weighed, and there's no judgement. To reach Level 3: compare them and conclude.
Level 3 (Detailed)· 8/9 marks (band 7–9)
Thanet Earth, on the Isle of Thanet in Kent, is the UK's largest greenhouse complex. It has clear advantages. It grows about 400 million tomatoes, 33 million cucumbers and 24 million peppers a year, picked all year round, so the UK imports less salad and food miles are cut. Crops grow hydroponically in controlled warmth and light, giving high yields from a small area. Its combined heat and power plants supply electricity and heat, and their carbon dioxide is fed to the plants, so less is wasted. It also creates local jobs. However, there are disadvantages. The power plants burn natural gas, a fossil fuel, so it still adds to climate change. The greenhouses were built on farmland, and their lights can be seen far away at night, causing light pollution. Overall, the advantages outweigh the disadvantages, because it greatly increases UK food supply efficiently, but it is not fully sustainable while it depends on natural gas.
Why this level: Detailed, accurate evidence on both sides, weighed to reach a qualified, supported judgement. This is Level 3.