9 marks · about 9 minutes
To what extent have TNCs brought more advantages than disadvantages to an LIC or NEE you have studied?
To what extent means: Weigh up how far something is true, with evidence on both sides, then give a clear judgement.
Level 1 (Basic)· 3/9 marks (band 1–3)
Shell brought jobs to Nigeria but also caused oil spills. I think the disadvantages are worse.
Why this level: Simple points with no detail, and a judgement that isn't explained. To reach Level 2: explain the advantages and disadvantages of a named TNC, with facts.
Level 2 (Clear)· 5/9 marks (band 4–6)
Shell brought Nigeria jobs, taxes that fund the government, and investment in pipelines, roads and training. However, it also caused harm: in 2008, two spills from Shell pipelines polluted creeks near Bodo, and in 2014 Shell agreed a £55 million settlement. Gas flaring also polluted the air.
Why this level: Clear advantages and disadvantages with accurate facts. But they aren't weighed, and there's no judgement. To reach Level 3: compare them, including who benefits and for how long, then conclude.
Level 3 (Detailed)· 8/9 marks (band 7–9)
Shell, a British TNC, brought Nigeria important advantages. It created jobs, paid taxes and royalties that fund the government, and invested in pipelines, roads and training. Oil has been central to Nigeria's economy: crude oil made up between about 65% and 81% of its exports in each quarter of 2024. However, the disadvantages have been serious. In 2008, two spills from Shell pipelines polluted creeks near Bodo, killing fish and damaging mangroves, and in 2014 Shell agreed a £55 million settlement. Gas flaring polluted the air, and a UN Environment Programme study in 2011 found that cleaning up Ogoniland could take 25 to 30 years. Much of the profit also went abroad, rather than staying in Nigeria. In 2025, Shell sold its onshore company to a group of mainly Nigerian firms. Overall, the economic advantages were real, but they were shared unevenly, while the environmental damage will last for decades, so the disadvantages outweigh them for the people of the Niger Delta.
Why this level: Detailed, accurate evidence on both sides, weighed with attention to who benefits and for how long, leading to a justified judgement. This is Level 3.