9 marks · about 9 minutes
Using an example, assess how far management reduced the risk from an extreme weather event in the UK.
Assess means: Weigh up how important or successful something is, then make a judgement.
Link it
Use the facts from:
- The Somerset Levels floods (Somerset Levels and Moors, south-west England, December 2013 to February 2014)
Level 1 (Basic)· 3/9 marks (band 1–3)
The Somerset Levels flooded in 2014. They pumped the water away and dredged the rivers. This helped.
Why this level: A named event and two measures, but no detail on how they reduced the risk or their limits. To reach Level 2: describe what was done, with facts, and explain how each reduced the risk.
Level 2 (Clear)· 5/9 marks (band 4–6)
In winter 2013 to 2014, the Somerset Levels had one of the wettest winters on record, and about 65 km² flooded. During the flood, the Environment Agency pumped water away with 40 permanent and 25 temporary pumps. Afterwards, about 8 km of the Rivers Parrett and Tone were dredged so they could carry more water, and the 20-Year Flood Action Plan raised roads and banks.
Why this level: Clear, accurate management with facts, explained. But it doesn't assess how far it worked, or the limits. To reach Level 3: weigh up what management can and can't do, then judge how far it reduced the risk.
Level 3 (Detailed)· 8/9 marks (band 7–9)
On the Somerset Levels, about 18% of the land lies below sea level, and in winter 2013 to 2014 repeated Atlantic storms brought one of the wettest winters on record. About 65 km² flooded, and villages such as Muchelney were cut off for weeks. During the flood, the Environment Agency ran a huge pumping operation, with 40 permanent and 25 temporary pumps, which lowered the floodwater. Afterwards, from 31 March 2014, about 8 km of the Parrett and Tone were dredged, so the rivers could carry more water. The 20-Year Flood Action Plan combined dredging with raised roads and banks, more pumping and tree planting upstream to slow runoff. These measures reduced the risk, especially of villages being cut off. However, dredging alone cannot stop floods as extreme as 2014's, and high tides in the Bristol Channel can still hold back river water. Overall, management reduced the risk considerably, but only a mix of measures maintained over many years can manage it, not remove it.
Why this level: Detailed, accurate facts on management during and after the flood, with its limits weighed and a clear judgement on "how far". This is Level 3.