9 marks · about 9 minutes
To what extent is recent climate change caused by human activities?
To what extent means: Weigh up how far something is true, with evidence on both sides, then give a clear judgement.
Level 1 (Basic)· 3/9 marks (band 1–3)
Humans burn fossil fuels, which gives off carbon dioxide and makes the Earth warmer. Volcanoes can change the climate too.
Why this level: One human cause and one natural cause, stated simply, with no explanation or judgement. To reach Level 2: explain several human causes and how they add greenhouse gases, and say how natural causes work.
Level 2 (Clear)· 5/9 marks (band 4–6)
Human activities add greenhouse gases to the atmosphere, which trap more heat. Burning fossil fuels in power stations and cars releases carbon dioxide. Cattle and rice paddies release methane. Cutting down forests means less carbon dioxide is absorbed. There are also natural causes: changes in the Earth's orbit cause ice ages, and big eruptions can cool the Earth.
Why this level: A clear explanation of human and natural causes. But it doesn't weigh them against each other or reach a judgement. To reach Level 3: explain why natural causes can't explain recent warming, and conclude how far it's human.
Level 3 (Detailed)· 8/9 marks (band 7–9)
Human activities have greatly increased greenhouse gases. Burning fossil fuels for electricity, transport and industry releases carbon dioxide; cattle and rice paddies release methane; and deforestation releases carbon and leaves fewer trees to absorb it. These gases trap more heat, enhancing the greenhouse effect. Natural factors also change the climate. Changes in the Earth's orbit explain the cycle of ice ages, and big eruptions such as Pinatubo in 1991 cool the Earth for a year or two. However, natural causes don't fit recent warming. Orbital changes take tens of thousands of years, far too slow to explain warming since the mid-20th century, and eruptions only cool the climate briefly. The sun's output hasn't risen enough to explain it either. The IPCC says human influence on warming is unequivocal. Overall, natural factors have changed the climate in the past and still cause short-term changes, but recent climate change is mainly caused by human activities.
Why this level: Detailed explanation of both human and natural causes, with evidence used to weigh them and a clear, supported judgement. This is Level 3.